Mon 26 Jun 2006
The Beijing Tea Scam & Variations: Traveler Beware
Posted by Mark Baker under Beijing , Shanghai , Travel TipsThe following caveat was written by Roddy Flagg, owner and administrator of Chinese-Forums.com. It is being reprinted here with permission and as a “public service” reminder to appeal to common sense when traveling in Beijing, Shanghai, or anywhere else.
Roddy writes:
A friend of mine just got caught out by this while visiting Beijing, and I figured I’d write this up in the hope that it might save some others some hassle . . .
I’m sure these and variations are in operation in other cities in China and worldwide, and a general warning to be on your guard when you’re in tourist areas is always warranted, but here’s some details.
The Beijing Teahouse Scam
You are happily wandering around somewhere like Wangfujing or Tiananmen and a friendly English student starts chatting to you. He or she speaks very good English, is friendly and shows you around, maybe helps you buy a few gifts, and subsequently suggests you go for a cup of tea at a nice teahouse he / she knows. The teahouse will be very nice, you will have some very nice tea, but you will feel slightly disturbed by the fact that they served tea without letting you see a menu, or that the menu has no prices on. You will assume this is how you do things in China.When the bill comes it will be ridiculous. My mate got presented with one that was approaching a four-figure RMB sum, for a pot of tea. Even if there is a tea house in Beijing legitimately serving tea at that price, it sure as hell doesn’t pour without asking what you want first.
What happens now varies - some scream and shout, some yell for the police, some pay up meekly, even if it requires the use of foreign currency or a credit card because they haven’t got enough RMB on them.
Variations:
1) Art galleries. ‘Art students’ strike up a conversation and invite you to their gallery. You’ll see at best second rate art at top-rate prices, and will be lucky to avoid a high-pressure sales pitch. Spend your time at a real gallery. Real galleries, for reference, do not send English students out onto the streets pretending to be art students.
2) Bars. Seems to be more common in Shanghai, and uses pretty girls in too much make-up rather than innocent looking ‘English students’ in tracksuits. This is clearly because Shanghai attracts a lower-class of tourist, but that’s beside the point.In any case, you’ll be in danger of paying a lot more for something than you should do, and at the very least you’re going to waste your time.
How to avoid it: Sad to say, if you are in an area where there are a lot of tourists in China, then 99% of people who approach you want something, whether they are postcard sellers, tour touts, Mao watch merchants, or scam artists as described above. Do not go anywhere which will involve spending money - be it a teahouse, a gift shop, an art gallery or a restaurant - with these people. If you are convinced that someone who approached you while you were standing on a street corner with your upside-down map and a copy of the Lonely Planet is genuine, fine - but go to a place of your choosing, and laugh in the face of anyone who gives you something you didn’t order, or presents you a price-free menu.
You can read the follow-up discussion and more information about these types of traveler scams in China at Chinese-Forums.com. Our thanks to Roddy for the warning and permission to share it via The Chinese Outpost.
July 12th, 2006 at 4:13 am
Thankfully in China I was never caught in by any of those scams.
Did speak to someone in my hostel who had just arrived in Shanghai who had fallen for the tea scam. Some guys and girls had come up to them then half an hour after meeting they suggested they go to a tea ceremony. Got there and the guys said ‘we’re guys we will all pay for the girls so split it between us’ . They were told it was 35 RMB/cup and there was a handling fee for each cup. They weren’t thinking clearly or they would have seen that there is no way that each cup could have been 35 each as they had 6 cups and paid 400RMB each. I think something to note is also that lots of young people don’t like tea ceremonies as they think it’s rather an old thing to do. Or at least none of my chinese friends like them.
There are loads of other scams that affect foreigners in China. Another is the 2 menu thing where one is English and crazy prices and the chinese one is reasonable. I remember in Xi’an one restaurant which was not that good was charging 90RMB for main courses on the English menu so I asked for the Chinese. Eventually they brought it and we compared one thing which was 8 on the Chinese menu and 30 on the English menu. They then grabbed the menus off us and we walked out of there. Other restaurants when they saw I had found it out, were perfectly happy to let us have the Chinese price. I can’t read Chinese but they always have the Chinese next to the English for the waitresses and it’s just a case of cross-referencing. In lots of places it’s just a case of asking them to show you where one dish appears on the Chinese menu.
July 12th, 2006 at 7:02 pm
A lot more clever and creative, as far a scams go, than those going around China when I first got there in 1993. Back then, there were still two currencies in China, RenMinBi (RMB) and Foreign Exchange Currency (FEC), which we foreign experts were paid in.
RMB was the more fluid, and so people would stop us on the street with, “Hello, Change Money!?” They were willing to trade in dollars too, but after FEC was done away with, the payoff for the black market “Change Money” folks lessened somewhat.
Oh, and the scam part: Never happened to me, but they’d take a person’s FEC or USD, count out the RMB, then sleight-of-hand keep some of it back before handing the wad of bills over…and running away.
Still happens, no doubt, but surely less than before.
October 15th, 2007 at 6:36 am
I just got scammed last evening. Same old style: so called students walking along with you, taking you to a tea tasting shop and at the end pulling up 1000s of RMB bill. Didn’t realize I was being fleeced and paid only my part 575 RMB on Amex. Got back, googled, and figured the whole thing is a scam. So, went back to the same shop this evening along with my two chinese coleagues, we argued with them about their scam, threatened them we’ll report to the license authority and call the police. They got scared and returned my 575. We didn’t have to yell at them, just a threat at normal tone level. I’ll also dispute the credit card charge and if I am lucky, Amex will ding them even more. Bastards! they deserve it.
So, don’t feel stupid for falling for the scam and keep quite. Go back, preferably with a chinese friend, threaten them and get your money back.
January 1st, 2008 at 10:14 pm
I got back from a week in Beijing a few days ago, and in the time I was there, I was almost scammed at least a dozen times. I’m sure it has to do in part to the fact that I was in a lot of the touristy places and I was also travelling alone.
All of the scams involved either tea, art, or taxis, all of which I had read about prior to going there (thank God!), and so I was lucky to have avoided being scammed at all (though I’m sure I got ripped off at the market, though that’s another story).
My last day there, I was tired of people with fake smiles coming up to me to “practice their English,” so when it happened again I responded in French saying I didn’t speak English, and the girl started speaking in French! She said she also spoke Spanish. It’s a shame these people can’t get better work using those language skills…
April 19th, 2008 at 7:22 am
[…] I fell prey to one of the scam artists I read about on the web. Basically, it was the tea scam. We had also been approached by the art student scam […]